Why Real Estate Agents Change Brokerages: What the Data Shows and What to Evaluate
Last updated: November 18, 2026. Sources checked November 18, 2026.
When considering a brokerage move, the commission split is often an early consideration. A recent industry study suggests the real picture is broader. Compensation matters, but so do leadership, training, culture and what is happening inside your own office. Here is what the data says, what it does not say, and how to use it if you are weighing a move in Miami and New York.
The data in brief
The figures below come from the Agent Migration and Brokerage Model Performance Report, Q3 2026, published by Recruiting Insight with Lone Wolf Technologies (report announcement). The study analyzed closings records for 109,176 producing agents in four of the largest U.S. MLS markets, covering the Mid-Atlantic, Southeast, Mid-South and West, over eight quarters from Q4 2024 through Q3 2026 (Q3 2026 is July 1 to September 30, 2026), plus 200 hours of agent exit interviews.
An important limit: the announcement identifies four macro-regions and does not name the individual MLS. These figures are not national estimates. The published announcement does not provide separate findings for Miami or New York, so these figures should not be treated as local turnover estimates.
Five findings worth knowing
- Moving is common. In the markets studied, about 1 in 8 producing agents changed firms each year.
- A sales slump is a weak signal. Agents whose production fell by 25% or more were no more likely to move than other agents.
- Colleagues leaving matters more. When an office lost 20% or more of its agents to competing firms, the agents who remained were 1.9 times as likely to move. This is a statistical association, not proof that one departure causes another.
- Money is only part of it. Exit interviews pointed to several drivers, including compensation, leadership, training and culture. Many of these never appear in closing data.
- Top producers moved more in Q3 2026. During the quarter, 87 agents with at least $20 million in annualized sales volume changed firms, the highest count in the eight quarters studied, even as total moves declined.
What this means if you are considering a move
The findings suggest that production alone is not enough to explain agent departures.
That has two practical consequences. First, if colleagues are leaving your office, it is reasonable to ask why, but a wave of departures is not by itself a reason to follow. Second, if you are frustrated, try to name the actual problem. Is it the split, the lack of mentoring, slow answers on contracts, weak marketing, or tools that do not fit how you work? The clearer the problem, the easier it is to judge whether another brokerage would actually solve it.
What to evaluate in a brokerage
Use these five areas to compare options on substance rather than on the headline offer:
- Support. Who answers contract and compliance questions, how quickly, and whether transaction coordination and marketing help are included.
- Commission structure. The split, caps, every recurring fee, per-transaction fees and any entry or exit costs, calculated on your own expected production over a full year.
- Technology. CRM, transaction management and marketing tools, and whether they are included or billed separately.
- Training. Ongoing education, coaching and real access to experienced brokers, not only onboarding.
- Office stability. Leadership tenure, how the office has grown or shrunk recently, and how the brokerage keeps agents informed.
Ask for specifics in writing and talk to agents who already work there.
Before you decide
Review your current independent-contractor agreement, especially notice terms, compensation on pending deals and any non-solicitation clause. Listings and pending transactions do not move automatically when you change brokerages. If you work in Florida, our guide on how to switch real estate brokerages in Florida walks through the state filing and the transition step by step. In New York, check the licensing requirements with the New York Department of State, Division of Licensing Services before you start.
FAQ
Are these figures valid for Miami or New York?
No. The published announcement does not provide separate findings for Miami or New York, so these figures should not be treated as local turnover estimates.
Does the study show that office departures cause agents to leave?
No. It shows an association between an office losing many agents and higher odds that others move. Other factors may explain both.
Is a higher split the best reason to switch?
Not necessarily. Compare total annual cost and value, including support, tools, training and stability, at your own production level.
Thinking about your next step?
If you want to talk through your situation in Miami and New York, you can request a confidential conversation with Piero Ruggeri or explore careers at Cosmore.
Disclaimer
This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Brokerage agreements and state rules differ. Review your contract and, where needed, consult a qualified attorney before acting.
Sources
More to read
Does New York Have Real Estate License Reciprocity With Florida? How to Work Both Markets
Read article
How to Switch Real Estate Brokerages in Florida: DBPR Steps, Timing and a Checklist for Miami Agents
Read article